conformity vs individuality in schools
This may sound like an outlandish problem, but this is what the average teenager goes through. They develop their position by effectively synthesizing* at least three of the sources. Conformity should be enforced only to the point where it isn't affecting students' mental and physical health due to loss of sleep, increases sociability, and teaches responsibility and independence. Do school uniforms make a difference or not? Social conformity is a key motive for school uniforms. This quotation accurately sums up the problems of our education system. Conformity is typically motivated by a person's identification with a specific group. However, conformity that protects the overall well-being of the groupmutually deciding to respect private property, for instancecan help societies succeed. Deweys vision for education could not be any farther from the truth of how todays school systems operate. For example, a guest, who got invited to a birthday party, does not really like eating vegetables. A later start time could also change the times for after-school activities for many students. Generally, yes; though individuals prioritize fitting in to varying degrees, virtually everyone who interacts with society conforms to it in some way. Janie finds out that her second attempt to marriage does not give what she desires, and it is only in her condemned marriage that Janie finally achieves her true love and happiness. That is why Conroe High Schools principal, Dr. Weatherly, should change the schools schedule to have less, but longer, classes in a single day to create a less stressful environment for the students and teachers benefit. Press Telegram: 20 Years Pass Since Long Beach Unifieds Historic School Uniform Policy. 2 Pages. Conformity versus individuality of students has been a huge debate among educationists, parents and child psychologists. Public school is one of the primary sources of education for many children in the United States, therefore it should be the school 's sole purpose to teach them the essential elements they need to succeed in life. Some experts. I agree with the point that was made in the video about conformity that occur in the American education system. However, he ate a lot of vegetable salad to please his vegan host and his family. For the last few years, schools across the United States have made conscious efforts to delay school start times. School uniforms have long been common in parochial schools, but a number of public schools also have uniform standards. Des Moines Independent School District that students do not "shed their constitutional rights to freedom of speech and expression at the schoolhouse gate." Students should not be forced to wear school uniforms because they restrict freedom of expression, promote conformity rather than individuality, and they are widely opposed by students. Christopher J. Ferguson Ph.D. on November 22, 2022 in Checkpoints. The three types of conformity according to Kelman are compliance (temporary behavioral change to receive a favorable reaction), identification (to be a member of a certain group but may stop when the individual leaves), and internalization (intrinsically motivated and relatively permanent behavioral change). The public schooling system in America edifies the paramount of individualism. If conforming to a norm will help your group solve a collective problem, its likely beneficial for you to follow suit. By the time a person has reached pubescence they are met with the overwhelming perception to stand out. Open Document. Knowing what you value will help you build the most meaningful life possible. But if we start a littler later, will be way healthier and more educated, and simply have a better attitude. This quote is supporting that if the school, Individuality And Conformity In Education, Individuality and Conformity in Education, Individuality should be encouraged to the point where students feel fulfilled, are creative, and can stand out amongst others in future occupations and colleges. From the beginning of the school year to the end, the most common thing that students least like, is homework. The following are the three types of conformity according to Kelman: It is a temporary behavior change since the compliance stops when there is no group pressure. From a political perspective, uniform detractors point to the right of individuals to free expression. Best Schools for Children Suffering from Sensory Processing Disorder. When conformity occurs because of fear, concern for ones social standing, or has dangerous consequences. Then why is it that there is so much emphasis put on conformity in the monotonous school system? A society needs people who are willing to draw their own conclusions in order to improve their life as well as those who live in the community. Conformity is typically defined as the expectation of employees to adapt to company policies and standards and use traditional business practices to complete job functions. Though it's often derided, conformity isn't necessarily a malevolent force. If she were to fill her roles as a woman she would not have married the third time and would have lived with how her life currently was. In researching this quotation, I was unable to verify that Mr. Everyone involved in our life has helped raise and teach us about almost everything as they all played a role in our lives. Many students across the nation are attending schools that have seven classes during each school day as their schedule, one of them being Conroe High School. textbook as, A social institution that transmits attitudes, knowledge, beliefs, values, norms, and skills to its members through formal systematic training. Yet despite the many essential benefits that education offers, only 34% of Americans have a lot of confidence in our public schools.. Brown, gene. Although, America makes it indispensable for students to take compulsory classes as a way of conformity it still sanctions the students to express their individualism with our dressing, our cull of electives and extra Co-curricular activities. Alfie Kohns essay How not to get into College, Heron Joness poem Somnambulist, and the episode Rosebud from the television show, The Simpsons, shows how finding true meaning and motivation in life can be very difficult and also reveals deeper meaning of how it is better to be motivated intrinsically rather than extrinsically. This is especially true as kids get older and can become resentful of their inability to choose personal clothing styles. Brown, g. (2021, September 17). Thus, the two types of conformity work together to shift behavior and encourage social cohesion. The fact that the school system cares more about the student dress code than their education is an issue in itself. When we consider whether or not to implement a school uniform pot- icy, we need to understand the validity of each proponent's arguments. Uniforms may simply involve wearing a standard T-shirt or top. Soon, your in class and can barely manage to stay awake. A simple ideathat your side is awake to the secret way things are while everyone else sleepwalksmade its way across intense ideological divides. A study has proven that lack of sleep will affect a teenagers life in a negative way, Overtime, not obtaining enough sleep can hurt students healthy, safety, social life, and school career. (National Sleep foundation 1) Due to teenagers naturally not being able to fall asleep till later in the night and forcing students to wake up severely early in the morning for school, they are exhausted. The fairness of teaching students knowledge they will most likely never use for anything other than to pass a standardized test should called into question and evaluated. Parents need to be careful while administering drugs to their kids. She has been teaching social science courses both in the undergrad and graduate levels. Conformity was first studied by Arthur Jenness(1932) who asked research participants to individually estimate how many beans does a bottle contain. This could easily be fixed by reformatting the school day. How Can Parents Help Their Teens Explore their Sexuality? Although Bostein points out Americas education system seems to be the main issue in preparing our children for the future, he is a bit too extreme with this ideas. Someone taught, to be sure, but they were not products of a school system, and not one of them was ever graduated from a secondary school are high school dropouts, yet we praise them for all they have done. School Dress codes do not allow students to completely express their individuality. Matthew Legge on November 3, 2022 in Are We Done Fighting? Their prose demonstrates a consistent In comparison, psychological studies which are related with individuality include twin studies and adoption studies (nature vs nurture). Essay Sample Check Writing Quality. If we as a society choose to base schooling off of the guidelines of conformity, the individuality in each and every student will soon be lost due to being forced to comply to the school system, therefore hindering students sense of individuality. Conformity came from the Latin word conformare which means to form. and updated on 2021, September 17, Difference Between Similar Terms and Objects. One reason is called social proof; its common to assume that if most other people are doing something, it must be correct. If keeping our children healthier means more money, its worth. The tussle between schools efforts to conform and kids desire to express their individuality is best portrayed in the movie Stepford Children, in which the behavior of children is modified to assimilate in the society to the extent they become robotic. As Dewey said, The notion that the essentials of elementary education are the three Rs mechanically treated, is based upon ignorance of the essentials needed for realization of democratic ideals. Students lose themselves once they reach high school, cemented in the same pattern of just trying to get the work done, never actually enjoying learning. This arrangement will lead to sleep deprivation. Individuality leads to innovation and strengthens a society unlike conformity, which sets limits on progress. An education system based off of forcing individual and different students to all follow the exact same course standard should be outlawed due to this being an outdated guideline of teaching. In this forum I will be discussing the quote from Mark Twian, "I have never let my schooling interfere with my education". Mass public schooling has created a divide amongst the foundation of whether to prioritize individuality or conformity. Nowadays people are choosing not to study they just want to be on the internet and be playing video games because they are conforming to the society new ways of not wanting to study or even finish school. However, we do conform to a certain degree with rigid school timetables (as visually perceived in Source B) and compulsory classes. The common reason students don't like school uniforms is they go against their ability to express individuality through clothing styles. Conformity is a type of social influence involving a change in belief or behavior in order to fit in with a group. Its eleven oclock, every last paper has been written. Individuality And Conformity In Education Though individuality is important to the growth of public school attendees, it must also be balanced by social pressure. 107 0 obj <>stream Public school or Private school: which ones better for your teen, Alternative School Options for Troubled Teens. If schools start later, this can affect after school activities such as clubs and sports. Gutting and Edmundson both blame the structure of the education system, but at the same time it sounds like the change needs to come only from students. Preteens are forced to find themselves at the same time as they feel they must fit in with everyone . What creates that feeling of grudgingness? But despite its evolutionary roots, conformity is not universally beneficial and can prove dangerouseither to individuals or to the group itselfwhen its resulting norms and practices are never questioned. Individuality vs. Conformity: The Issue Behind School Uniforms P. Caruso Published 1 September 1996 Education NASSP Bulletin When we consider whether or not to implement a school uniform pot- icy, we need to understand the validity of each proponent's arguments. svg.mzr-nav-icon { For example, a foreign student adopted a new way of life; however, he went back to his previous culture when he went back to his own country. The pressure to buy the latest fashion can create stress on students, especially those who come from families without the financial means to keep up with classmates. The current school start time is unacceptable when thought about logically, and we must make the changes to have school start at a later time. Ran D. Anbar M.D. During school, students follow rigid schedules and high . An adults brain is developed enough to understand and remember multiple topics in a day, but doesnt have to, whereas a student has to remember many topics, in a wide range of subject areas, but is not mentally developed well enough to do so. The Positive and Negative Side of Peer Pressure You Need to Know, Peer Pressure and Teens: Social Media is the Culprit. I agree with this source, starting schools later could enhance students school performance academically and athletically. 83 FEATURES Individuality vs. Conformity: The Issue Behind School Uniforms By Peter Caruso Peter Caruso is a junior high school English teacher in Mesa, Ariz. Conformity denotes a wide-ranging phenomenon in which people (intentionally or unintentionally) shift their behavior or beliefs to fit in with a larger group. America has come a long way in its education system. Some are numerical and scientific geniuses, while others have an enviable passionate way with words. The educational system is flawed and it does not prepare students to become successful adults. With a uniform standard, you can minimize the effect clothes have on economic and social barriers, which can improve overall school spirit and the sense of community. Groupthink is often, but not always, spurred by a desire to conform. Difference Between Similar Terms and Objects. Why do kids act out? Even one voice of dissent can dampen a collective urge to conform to harmful behaviors. Jeffery Zou Mr. Stoker Class 3 January 30, 2017 School of Irony: Individuality versus Conformity Students are taught in school to be unique and aim for the fulfillment of their personal goals. In my opinion, they educated us on things that our time in school did not. Psychology Today 2023 Sussex Publishers, LLC. Requiring uniforms has pros and cons, often centering on the balance between individual expression and conformity. Though psychological research has examined many aspects of conformity and related concepts, researchers have typically focused on two main types of conformity: informational and normative.
