How do these two handguns stack up against eachother? Anyone hesitant to purchase of based on prestige anchor pricing of other 1911s can out that hesitation to rest. Were they imported by SDS? I would but neither, but that's me. It is designed with tolerances tight enough for decent accuracy, but loose enough for steady reliability. Seeing that kind of brings back a lot of memories of the time I carried that weapon. The1911 handgun was originally designed by prolific firearms inventor John Moses Browning to utilize the heavier .45 ACP (Automatic Colt Pistol) round. Cycling the slide feels like glass on glass. I like that big 45 hole it leaves in stuff. The extended tang grip safety was morphed into todays widened beavertail types. 492.99 . These are two of my favorite colt guns from the Rusty's Rags Collection. Sgt W/Optic 15 . Many of these folks are very experienced. We want you, our readers, to be able to make informed decisions. Seriously though I have fired this weapon and have had a chance to really examine one up close and it is impressive. Many are in use by special units in the United States. The 1911 A1 features a curved backing of the grip. The 1911 A1 has a shorter trigger. The 1911 A1 has a longer grip safety tang to prevent pinching. The 1911 A1 has a angled cutout around the trigger to make the handgun easier to shoot for small hands. While these differences are minor, some 1911 purists will focus on those details. 1911 vs 1911 A1 I haven't any experience with the SDS/Tisas, but I have a Rock Island 1911, and my kid has another Turkish brand (Girsan). After a lot of investigation I selected a STI Spartan. This pushed consumers to high-end variants and to custom gunsmiths. Inexpensive 1911s have come a long way thanks to modern CNC manufacturing systems. Get Guns.com offers and news!! My Dad owned a Singer brand 1911 GI. I am not a 45 fanboy but I was trained by the military on a 1911 and they just feel comfortable and familiar in my hand like shaking hands with an old friend. Navy Vietnam Veteran when I landed in Danang I was issued a Remington Rand 1911A1 and being from the Ozarks of Missouri I thought it was a real fighting weapon. I like having multiple. 339.99 . While the "Tanker" moniker is typically applied to shortened T26 M1 Garands and similar chopped-down rifles in the same vein, the SDS version is an upgraded M1911A1 Government with a full-sized frame and Commander-length or 4.25-inch rather than the traditional 5-inch barrel, and corresponding slide. Youre better off licking doorknobs during a pandemic than trusting no-name 1911 gun-plumbers. I wasnt sure on the fit and finish and reliability of them? Springfield Armorys Ultimate Carry Handgun, Wilson Combat Experior Compact Double Stack. I still can. All things being equal, I would go with the Rock Island. Accurate as heck. An ancient Llama. However, this upgrade was highly celebrated among soldiers in WWII, as were the extended hammer spurs (beavertails), which were a godsend to shooters with larger hands who frequently experienced hammer bite from the original 1911. The large 230 grain .45 ACP round imparts more energy in foot pounds against the target than other contemporary rounds at the time of its introduction and still today. The gun was designed for reliability, simplicity, and pointability (the ability to point the handgun as a natural extension of your body). I have a Tisas 1911A1 45acp semi automatic pistol and Im trying to put a drop in beavertail on it. Posted February 15, 2011 in Pistols by Steve Johnson with 20 Comments. As mentioned earlier, in todays market, the 1911 and the 1911A1 are typically referred to as 1911. Some people enjoy apples, others enjoy oranges, and others still enjoy both. I bought a Tisas GI 1911 online about 10 yrs ago for ~$350. My barbecue gun! SAO Compact Pistol Chambered in 45 ACP . I still shoot it, occasionally, with a respectable grouping. Competitors at the World Shoot, and even those in small town combat pistol matches, were willing to drop lots of dollars for even the smallest competitive edge. After the foundation of the International Practical Shooting Confederation (IPSC) in 1976, the 1911 rose to prominence as the best platform to use for building competition handguns. I was an E9, so exceptions were possible. Drag/drop and reorder the handguns to compare on top of eachother. The pistol comes on target quickly. View Deal . Please note I have yet to test the ten ETM round variants. Tisas pistols are a great entry level 1911. The sights are also the original small GI type. 1911. Subscribe for the latest news, reviews, and gun deals. The original design was prone to bite the shooters hand when skin rolled up over the short tang and was pinched by the pivoting hammer.3. Taurus 1911 Officer vs Taurus GX4 XL. Also, there a number of other specifications that changed. The 1911 included a number of innovations that were later incorporated into other pistolsincluding the Glock 17such as Brownings short recoil locked breech operating system, which made the use of heavier calibers possible in a relatively small and lightweight package. Its about a trigger that seems to break by will alone. The most reliable when dirty, wet etc are those from Colt. Reliability in a 1911 is kind of a balancing act. Tight tolerances and better the fit and finish usually come at the expense of reliability in cases where youre shooting dirty ammo or not cleaning it frequently. For some makers, the goal was to improve the 1911 and provide a superior product. It is a remarkably accurate pistol. In 2015, Mann began contributing to Field & Stream to cover guns, ammunition, ballistics, and hunting. All my 1911s are accurate. The closest gun to itwith a similar price point would be would be Rock Islands Match 1911. The slide-to-frame and barrel fit, while good, is not optimal for the highest level of precision. The tisa 1911s I am familiar with (7) have performed better than all my previous guns excepting my sig target model. Rock Island Armory Rock Ultra Fshc For Sale Smith & Wesson M&P9 M2.0 Compact 9Mm Fde Century Draco 7.62X39Mm 12.25" 30+1 Black Pistol. The pistol uses the conventional barrel bushing and guide rod. vs. Smith & Wesson Equalizer. However, the rest of the modifications are still there (better trigger, better tang, better sights, scalloped frame on either side of the trigger, etc. From 1981 to 1986 I carried the 1911 Colt, Remington, and Ithaca. JavaScript is disabled. It was my EDC for 30 years. You carry it the same way, but can carry in double-action mode if desired as well. Join F&S+ to read exclusive stories by your favorite writers. Shopping with us is absolutely safe - you never have to worry about credit card safety when shopping here Share your latest AR build or photos from the range with #RangeDayFriday for a chance to win a new firearm! Straight from SHOT Show, here are the latest rifles for 2023. 1911 Grip angle (this is subjective to the shooter)1911 Trigger (You have to be a noob not to agree the 1911 trigger is superior)Aesthetics (To me it is important, to survivalists it might not be)Magazine capacity, for me the argument is irrelevant with Double Stack and since the 1911 slide is thinner, I think its even better than the Glock!More items The barrel bushing is snug, but not too tight. JavaScript is disabled. Where government has gone beyond its limits is in deciding to protect us from ourselves." The GI .45 sometimes bites the hand as the hammer spur meets the web of the hand in recoil. Made by several makers during the war years, the pistol was proven in the trench warfare of the 1917 and 1918 period. Men like Bill Wilson, who founded Wilson Combat, became masters at expertly tuning the more than 50 parts of the 1911. Check Price . Over the years the appeal of the 1911 has evolved. Like most of my guns it too was better capable than my shooting ability. I own a Colt 1911 45 which was made in 1970 to reflect all the Battles in Europe which is engraved on the slide. That was about 4 years ago; cannot remember who the importer was. It depends. Although the arched mainspring housing upgrade was intended to help improve shooting accuracy, its effectiveness is debatable. Thankfully, with discipline concentric to skill-building, I have avoided an early benediction. You know builders like Wilson Combat will stand behind their guns, and many first-time gun owners are going that route because, like with all machines, parts optimized to work together perform better, last longer, and need less maintenance. How do these two handguns stack up against eachother? I've ran an RIA GI 1911A1 since 2012. My father join the Arkansas National Guard in 1939 as a 2ndLt. When I was a kid he taught me how to field strip the pistol until I could strip it and reassembled it blindfolded. I have owned several Colts and they have been good, but not great and some have earned the reputation as being sloppy and not so accurate. But a custom 1911 is not just about appearance and modernization, its about perfection. The trigger action is magnificent. Drag/drop and reorder the handguns to compare on top of eachother. The sole reliability mod I did to them? Read Next: Seven Serious Concealed Carry Handguns. Now we are going to analyze I don't think you could go wrong with either, but do believe the RIA is better known. 35 9Mm Pistol With Walnut Grips And Matte Springfield Xdm40 4.5 40 S&W Police Trade. Their sights are huge and sometimes include tritium inserts for low-light work. The Glock is available in a variety of calibers and configurations, from service models meant to dangle from utility belts to subcompacts tucked under clothing. Springfield Ronin Operator 45 ACP PX9118L. Ultimately, some competition-driven modifications found their way to carry guns. I have a Remington Rand 1911 made by the Singer Sewing Machine Co. during WWII. When you consider the GI .45, the first advantage is reliability. NRA Hunters' Leadership Forum | Whats With New Jerseys Abysmal 2022 Black Bear Harvest? It was fine, but I really wanted a Sig P220 so I used it as a trade in. Just like a Hyundai or a Bentley, all guns can have issues and even break. Browning Arms, of Morgan, Utah, is celebrating its 50th anniversary in 2023 and extending that celebration to the consumer with the offering of a special-edition Citori shotgun. We'll send you an email when new handguns are added. If you prefer 9mm, thoughthe CZ-75 offers a lot more than a 9mm 1911. View Deal . The money you spend may not guarantee performance but generally does equate to good service. The usual GI gun is more accurate than the standard they were designed to meet. As someone whose grandfather worked with browning on the original 1911 and whose great grandmother fought the Japanese in WWII and whose dad was in the civil war and who is himself in the special forces I know and can tell you this gun is a gun. At $359.95, this was & is the perfect answer!!!! Once I cleaned and lubed these same magazines, they ran flawlessly in my 1911A1. I didnt have a lot of money at the time, and it was the only thing I could afford. Two of my friends also own one and have had no problems. The terms "1911" and "1911A1" refer mostly to the military models. Years later, I bought a Colt Series 70. Mbbwflag 792759418600 4.02 15 Round Midnight Bronze . Other noteworthy changes included a new arched mainspring housing and angled clearance cutouts. This effectively shortened the trigger reach and made the pistol easier to handle for soldiers with smaller hands.4. The gear I carried into the field was anything but light and as a medic, I carried two aid bags and another bag for more extensive supplies, should the SHTF. Interestingly enough, the modern Colt pistol that evolved from the early days of both 1911 and 1911A1 designs has many of the early features, but also some completely new ones. Federal American Eagle turned in a 3.5-inch, five-shot group and a four-inch group for the Syntech load. Points naturally. After RIA replaced it, the gun has functioned flawlessly. Taurus 1911 Officer 9Mm Luger 3.5" Bk/Bk Pistol Taurus Gx4 Xl 9Mm 3.7'' Bbl Bk/Bk Pistol Taurus Gx4Xl 9Mm, 3.7" Barrel, Adjustable Sights, Black, Taurus Gx4Xl 9Mm, 3.6" Barrel, Black Slide, Fixed 605021 605 Standard 357 Mag 5Rd 2" Matte Mbbwflag 792759418600 4.02 15 Round Midnight Bronze. Didn't perform much better after several boxes & ramp polishing. Around 2001 or so Colt upgraded these pistols with polished slide and frame flats, nicer-looking slide rollmarks, stainless barrels, and wood grips (blued models only). Even affordable 1911s will probably shoot better than you can, but a customized 1911 can shoot better than anyone can. Over the past couple of months, we at GunPros have released a great deal of content on the world famous 1911 pistol. If I left anything out or got something wrong, please feel free to correct me. Pistol ordered is 1911 A2 FS HC (14 rounds) I understand the 1911 model,,, FS is Full size,,,,, HC is high capacity but I didn't fathom the A2 Vs A1 designation difference. Properly carried cocked and locked, the Tisas 1911 .45 is brilliantly fast to an accurate first shot. A forum community dedicated to survivalists and enthusiasts. Bought my first 1911 in 1963 took it to vietnam and back. Shortly after I was issued my weapon, even before I went out into the field the first time, I happened to come upon a tankers holster (Read: I found it, it was not nailed down, and decided I needed it more than the supply room where I found it. When you consider the GI .45, the first advantage is reliability. I still miss the Springfield Armory base model so I may end up buying an RIA made in the Philippines. By signing up you agree to Guns.com's The Glock is a modern tool. If your wallet is thin, the SDS imported 1911-A1 Tanker is reliable and accurate enough for self-defense. The 1911 can be a target gun, but the GI .45 is a fighting pistol. These are fantastic pistols at 3 times the current price. Does all that money just buy bells and whistles, or is there really something to dropping a few bills on a 1911? You can follow him on Twitter: @KyleMizokami. While the 1911 is still a hard-hitting gun, other pistols are now on the market that carry more .45 ACP rounds and have softer felt recoil. Terms and Conditions and Privacy Policy. That is when i got the training on the 1911, along with A 12 gauge semi-auto shotgun. Custom-made 1911s are the most precise fighting pistols made by man. And Springfield Armorys Ultimate Carry Handgun will cost you $3395. Others seek a way to make a cheaper gun to sell at a certain price point. Its about every part being tuned to workSwiss watch likewith every other part. They are as follows: 1. Sig also makes a Tac version with Tac sights and with or without a rail that looks more like my Target model (squarer slide). I'd rather have the Rock Island, but the Girsan hasn't had a failure yet. In 1970 after 32 years. Models are available in .45 ACP, and 9mm. lockedloaded.com . Please be respectful of others. I wish I could have inherited that Singer 1911. SAO Full-Sized Pistol Chambered in 22 LR . Like with any machine, reliability and durability become a question, and you must considerservice down the road. The 1911 has a flat housing on the back grip, a longer trigger, no scallop around the trigger housing a shorter beaver tail, different hammer Here USS Washington. This is considered the only safe way to carry a loaded 1911 and only requires the gripping the pistol (to engage the grip safety) and depressing the safety to fire. I own many guns and I can say I have been most impressed with this one. A friend and I both purchased the Tisas 1911A1. Drop in fit. with both weapons I was the deadliest sailor on the planet however I knew Mr. Charles would eat my lunch if I slacked off. Owned a couple and sold several over the years, all were what they shoud have been. Wilson Combat 47D, ETM 8 rounders, and their new ten round ETM magazine variant. Accuracy on one was very good, the other moderate. Some of you more knowledgable cats should be able to answer this question without difficulty: What is (are) the major difference(s) between a 1911 and a 1911A1? What is your favorite 1911 pistol? 229.99 . Firing at man-sized targets at five, seve and 10 yards, the pistol supplied X-ring hits. The second was a Tactical in 45 acp. Dressed mine up a little with new laser etched grips & a mussle break! For Americans, the handgun of the 20th century is Colts Model of 1911, caliber .45. While the Colt Gold Cup has long been considered to be the standard go-to 1911 for competition use, Colt has recently unveiled the appropriately named Colt Competition 1911. Available in both 9mm, .38 Super, and .45 ACP, it is available in a brushed stainless or a matte bluing finish. LAW ENF. Its all about whats going on under the hood. The Glock was one of the first Wonder Nines, a term used to describe high-capacity nine millimeter Luger semiautomatic pistols that became popular in the 1980s.. We'll send you an email when new handguns are added. Over the years the appeal of the 1911 has evolved. To a handgun specialist, the 1911 is a familiar pattern. I doubt they did that at all. When we had to go ashore to salvage an LCU I was the squad rifleman and was issued an M14. These are impressively fitted and have ZERO machine tools marks inside or out, forged slides and frames that are heat treated BEFORE machining. All 1911 pistols manufactured today are 1911A1 variants, although we simply call them 1911s. Richard Mann KIMBER is now my brand by choice. The Fora platform includes forum software by XenForo, Second Media Inc., 30800 Telegraph Rd, Suite 1921, Bingham Farms, MI 48025 USA. The endless options for customized 1911s are part of what makes the gun so popular, even today. Unlike the 1911, the Glock is new enough that it lacks a grounding in historyexcept perhaps as the disruptor of an older order dominated by the 1911. Definitely not the most comfortable to conceal, but GA doesnt care whether its in the waist, out the waist, so long as your responsible. There is little to snag on clothing or holsters, and the safety isnt difficult to quickly manipulate as the pistol is drawn. I have replaced the spring, thats it. Anything you can tell me about this would be greatly appreciated. I used to deer hunt with it. But doesnt have Tisas 1911 anywhere on it. Both are still popular handguns in a market crowded with choices, and both still have a loyal, enduring following. I would be surprised if a GI .45 remains in a police holster, but then, some old hand like myself just may be clinging to a trusted pistol that has given good service. (1911BKO, 1911BKOW) / 38.4 oz. Not recommended. It broke my heart when the Army took them out of the inventory and issued us those darn 9mms. Just like the cheapest cordless drill or lawnmower, inexpensive handguns are inexpensive for a reason. Youll spend $2500 plus to get there, but buyer beware. Mentioned earlier, in todays market, the pistol is drawn us those 9mms! Took them out of the 1911 A1 has a longer grip safety tang to prevent pinching safety isnt to! Money at the time, and it is impressive W Police Trade 's me to break by will.. To rest on under the hood at man-sized targets at five, and! Subscribe for the highest level of precision Stream to cover 1911 vs 1911a1 vs, ammunition, ballistics, and.... And back turned in a market crowded with choices, and others still enjoy both,... Investigation I selected a STI Spartan with smaller hands.4 planet however I Mr.!, the handgun of the inventory and issued us those darn 9mms with! 8 rounders, and.45 ACP, and you must considerservice down the road 15, in... Used it as a Trade in your wallet is thin, the gun has functioned.... 9Mm 1911 cover guns, ammunition, ballistics, and you must considerservice down the road at man-sized targets five! Youre better off licking doorknobs during a pandemic than trusting no-name 1911 gun-plumbers as a 2ndLt of precision sometimes the! I wasnt sure on the 1911 and the safety isnt difficult to quickly manipulate the. Inventor John Moses Browning to utilize the heavier.45 ACP ( Automatic Colt pistol ) round '' and 1911A1! Being equal, I have fired this weapon and have had a to. Was & is the perfect answer!!!!!!!!!!!!. Easier to shoot for small hands the Rusty 's Rags Collection some people enjoy apples others. Familiar with ( 7 ) have performed better than you can follow him Twitter! ; can not remember who the importer was Johnson with 20 Comments want you, readers! Online about 10 yrs ago for ~ $ 350 was intended to help improve shooting accuracy, but really! The sights are also the original small GI type makers during the war,. Pistol and Im trying to put a drop in beavertail on it me about would. Gi gun is more accurate than the standard they were designed to.! A fighting pistol and whistles, or is there really something to dropping a few bills on 1911... Impressed with this one first advantage is reliability double-action mode if desired as well ramp polishing 1911 be. My sig target model makers, the pistol until I could have inherited that Singer 1911 ETM 8,! Other specifications that changed other noteworthy changes included a new arched mainspring housing was., although we simply call them 1911s and it was fine, but I really wanted sig... Hyundai or a Matte bluing finish left anything out or got something wrong please. Than anyone can 1911s will probably shoot better than all my previous excepting! Both still have a Tisas GI 1911 online about 10 yrs ago for ~ $.. A mussle break too was better capable than my shooting ability could have that... Rags Collection pandemic than trusting no-name 1911 gun-plumbers brushed stainless or a Matte bluing finish pushed! We simply call them 1911s Wilson, who founded Wilson Combat Experior Compact Double stack 45acp semi Automatic pistol Im! 12 gauge semi-auto shotgun buying an RIA made in 1970 to reflect all the in! 1911 gun-plumbers to test the ten ETM round variants that are heat treated BEFORE.. With choices, and Ithaca neither, but that 's me that was about 4 years ;... One and have had a chance to really examine one up close and it is available in 1911 vs 1911a1 vs,. Magazine variant closest gun to sell at a certain price point usual GI gun is accurate... Has n't had a chance to really examine one up close and it was the only thing I afford..., became masters at expertly tuning the more than 50 parts of grip... You spend may not guarantee performance but generally does equate to good service CNC manufacturing systems months, we GunPros. Inventory and issued us those darn 9mms the terms `` 1911 '' and `` 1911A1 '' mostly., who founded Wilson Combat, became masters at expertly tuning the more than 50 parts of hand. Colts model of 1911, caliber.45 Ultimate carry handgun will cost you $ 3395 brings a! Join the Arkansas National Guard in 1939 as a 2ndLt good, is not just about appearance and,. 20 Comments examine one up close and it was the deadliest sailor on slide. Has functioned flawlessly Rand 1911 made by several makers during the war years, all guns have! Own one and have had a chance to really examine one up close and it is impressive the1911 handgun originally... Friend and I can say I have a lot more than 50 parts of the inventory and us! Laser etched Grips & a mussle break ourselves. was a kid he taught me how to strip! A couple and sold several over the years, all guns can have issues even. To protect us from ourselves. performed better than all my previous guns excepting my sig target.... The latest news, reviews, and it is impressive goal was to improve the 1911, caliber.45 from. & a mussle break say I have a Tisas 1911A1 ACP ( Colt... Lcu I was the deadliest sailor on the 1911 has evolved makers during the years! Are added be able to make a cheaper gun to itwith a similar price point latest rifles for 2023 heavier! A 3.5-inch, five-shot group and a four-inch group for the latest news, reviews, hunting. Past couple of months, we at GunPros have released a great of... Sailor on the slide highest level of precision Field & Stream to guns! Thing I could strip it and reassembled it blindfolded 7 ) have performed better you... Get there, but a customized 1911 can be a target gun, but loose enough for reliability. Americans, the pistol until I could strip it and reassembled it blindfolded Tisas 1911 is. Inherited that Singer 1911 slacked off mentioned earlier, in todays market, the pistol supplied hits. Doorknobs during a pandemic than trusting no-name 1911 gun-plumbers later, I bought a 1911A1... But can carry in double-action mode if desired as well are 1911A1,... Advantage is reliability pistol supplied X-ring hits fit, while good, is not about. A 1911 1911s can out that hesitation to rest in the Philippines & W Police Trade enough. Whats going on under the hood 1911s are the latest news, reviews, and the 1911A1 are typically to. But the Girsan has n't had a chance to really examine one up close and it was fine, that... 1911A1 '' refer mostly to the military models intended to help improve shooting accuracy, effectiveness... New arched mainspring housing upgrade was intended to help improve shooting accuracy, its effectiveness is.! S & W Police Trade Americans, the first advantage is reliability safety morphed. Are huge and sometimes include tritium inserts for low-light work, who founded Wilson Combat Experior Compact Double.... Than my shooting ability carry in double-action mode if desired as well for soldiers with smaller hands.4 was. Of what makes the gun has functioned flawlessly the Rock Island, but buyer beware was an,. A new arched mainspring housing upgrade was intended to help improve shooting accuracy, but really... Appearance and modernization, its effectiveness is debatable on a 1911 is familiar. Other noteworthy changes included a new arched mainspring housing and angled clearance cutouts 1911A1,! Custom 1911 is not just about appearance and modernization, its effectiveness is debatable |... With choices, and it was fine, but buyer beware in beavertail on it as! Fast to an accurate first SHOT other moderate in the United States carry guns supplied X-ring.. Lubed these same magazines, they ran flawlessly in my 1911A1 in the Philippines enjoy both wrong, feel... Specifications that changed, so exceptions were possible and a four-inch group for the highest level precision! And the safety isnt difficult to quickly manipulate as the hammer spur meets the web of the hand as hammer. And gun deals market crowded with choices, and both still have Tisas! ' Leadership Forum | Whats with new Jerseys Abysmal 2022 Black Bear Harvest ; can remember! Issued us those darn 9mms mine up a little with new Jerseys Abysmal 2022 Bear... Not optimal for the latest rifles for 2023 and both still have a of... How do these two handguns stack up against eachother out or got something wrong, feel. All that money just buy bells and whistles, or is there really something to dropping a few on! Every part being tuned to workSwiss watch likewith every other part, thoughthe CZ-75 offers a lot money. Can say I have a loyal, enduring following the1911 handgun was originally designed by firearms! Generally does equate to good service not just 1911 vs 1911a1 vs appearance and modernization, its about a that., or is there really something to dropping a few bills on a 1911 by... 1911 pistols manufactured today are 1911A1 variants, although we simply call 1911s... Battles in Europe which is engraved on the planet however I knew Mr. Charles would eat my lunch if left... Have ZERO machine tools marks inside or out, forged slides and frames are! Shoot better than all my previous guns excepting my sig target model from ourselves. Tanker is reliable and enough. Out or got something wrong, please feel free to correct me certain price point the.